U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit, Judge Denny Chin, noted that Walker "plausibly alleged conditions that, perhaps alone and certainly in combination, deprive him of a minimal civilized measure of life's necessities," and that prison officials were "deliberately indifferent to this deprivation."
Thus his case was sent back to the lower court, where he will have the opporunity to explain why 6 men in a 2-man cell deprives him of minimal life necessities. According to Walker, his cellmates included gang members, and the "overcrowding, gang activities, violence [and] fights" in the cell placed Walker "in a situation to kill or be killed." Walker also claimed that his cell was unsanitary, with so much "urine on the floor” that "urin[e] or defecat[ion] would splatter." Walker complained to the warden and other prison officials to no avail.