James Averhart, Chief Warrant Officer IV, who as commander of the Quantico brig determined conditions of confinement, kept Pvt. Bradley Manning naked for 7 days, and in solitary confinement despite recomendations from doctors to release him He insists that the regulation gives him to authority to decide whether to relax confinement standards--even though the regulation says a prisoner "shall" be released if the medicos say so. Averhart argued that the word "shall" did not introduce a specific timeline for ending the confinement. "[T]he order is vague - it does say 'shall,' it does not say 'right now' or 'immediately,' sir - it still gives me the opportunity to evaluate," he said. http://peoplesworld.org/hearing-highlights-controversy-over-bradley-manning-jail-conditions/
James Averhart, Chief Warrant Officer IV, who as commander of the Quantico brig determined conditions of confinement, kept Pvt. Bradley Manning naked for 7 days, and in solitary confinement despite recomendations from doctors to release him He insists that the regulation gives him to authority to decide whether to relax confinement standards–even though the regulation says a prisoner “shall” be released if the medicos say so.
Averhart argued that the word “shall” did not introduce a specific timeline for ending the confinement. “[T]he order is vague – it does say ‘shall,’ it does not say ‘right now’ or ‘immediately,’ sir – it still gives me the opportunity to evaluate,” he said.
http://peoplesworld.org/hearing-highlights-controversy-over-bradley-manning-jail-conditions/